44 pages 1 hour read

bell hooks

Ain't I A Woman: Black Women and Feminism

Nonfiction | Essay Collection | Adult | Published in 1981

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapter 2

Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 2 Summary: “Continued Devaluation of Black Womanhood”

In this chapter, hooks examines the impact of slavery on the political and social status of Black women. Sexual violence targeting Black women did not end with slavery. Contemporary media continues to portray Black women as sexually promiscuous, which is consistent with the fundamentalist perception of women as sinful temptresses. Lack of attention to the rape of Black women is consistent with the perception that Black women are sexually permissive, which hooks traces back to slavery: “The designation of all black women as sexually depraved, immoral, and loose had its roots in the slave system” (52). White media portrayed Black men and women as innately immoral, and many believed that Black women were deserving of the abuse they experienced due to their moral status.

During Reconstruction (the post-Civil War period), Black women pushed back against these stereotypes by dressing well and emulating white women, but they were physically and verbally assaulted by people who wanted them to remain subjugated. Sexual violence against Black women was so common that activists published articles to draw attention to the matter. Their outrage was ignored by the white public, who internalized stereotypes about Black women. hooks explains that the prevalence of bias against Black women and the pervasiveness of sexual assault reveal the continued devaluation of Black women’s identities. This devaluation is systemic and intentional; it uses moral judgments to uphold white supremacy.

What is commonly referred to as the “Jim Crow era” marks a time of apartheid in the United States. hooks describes this period as a deliberate effort by white supremacists to maintain a social order of white dominance. Legislation and social norms affirmed this hierarchy, including bans on interracial marriages and extreme social anxiety about mixed-race relationships. White supremacists also used psychological tactics, convincing the white public that Black women were sexually promiscuous and that Black men were dangerous. These effective myths helped separate society into racial factions; however, they also created a system in which Black women could be used as sexual objects by white men while excluding them from the institution of marriage.

hooks states that in the 20th century, the social status of Black men changed while negative perceptions of Black women persisted. Laws restricting marriage between races were overturned, but hooks points out that while Black men were able to marry white women, relationships between white men and Black women remained uncommon. Viewers were more comfortable watching a white woman bring home a Black partner to meet her parents in the film Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner than they were seeing a white man fall in love with a Black woman in the soap opera Days of Our Lives. The disparity is evidence of the sexual politics of patriarchy. Both white women and Black men represent powerless social groups within a system of white supremacy; their alliance is not viewed as a threat. White men, however, comprise the dominant social group, and when a white man aligns himself with a Black woman, he invites her to join his status.

hooks recounts how Black women who do participate in relationships with white men are harassed and ridiculed by both others, Black and white. The devaluation of Black womanhood means that any choice made by a Black woman is open to criticism and complaint. Perceptions of Black women as matriarchs play on stereotypes and ignore their trauma and complex experiences within a patriarchal system.

Chapter 2 Analysis

In this chapter, hooks takes a historical approach to the theme of The Devaluation of Black Womanhood. She shows how after slavery, perceptions of Black women shifted to maintain a hierarchical structure of white supremacy, with Black women on the lowest tier. hooks explains that the biases and stereotypes that informed ideologies about Black women during Reconstruction still apply today, and these disparities were maintained through sexual violence.

hooks weaves the theme of The Impact of Patriarchal Culture into her study of Black womanhood. In Chapter 1, she explains how freedom was perceived by enslaved Black men as the ability to participate in the dominant culture—that is, white patriarchy. As Black men began to internalize and express patriarchal culture in their own homes and relationships, Black women were forced into subservience by sexism, and racism ensured their oppression outside of the home. In Chapter 2, hooks traces how this expression of patriarchal culture continued to impact the lives and perceptions of Black women after slavery ended. Widespread sexual assault of Black women, normalized during slavery, continued into the Reconstruction era. Additionally, Black women were ostracized by Christian ideas of femininity and purity, and stereotypes about Black women as innately sinful or temptresses pervaded American consciousness. hooks examines how these stereotypes endure today:

One has only to look at American television twenty-four hours a day for an entire week to learn the way in which black women are perceived in American society—the predominant image is that of the “fallen” woman, the whore, the slut, the prostitute. (52)

These negative and volatile stereotypes are rooted in patriarchal structures that intend to create a power disparity between white men and women. During slavery and in its aftermath, sexual violence committed against Black women was normalized by the perception of Black women as sexually promiscuous. White people believed that Black women invited sexual assault because of their assumed inferior morality. When Black women attempted to change how others perceived them, they were met with resistance and harassment from both Black and white parties. Even within Black communities, Black women who attempted to obtain positions outside of service or who emulated the mannerisms and styles of white women were viewed as self-important or delusional.

After slavery, white society was concerned about America’s racial future and social order. Concerns about Black and white people marrying one another led to a series of legislative acts, which enforced racial apartheid. New stereotypes emerged, each representing The Intersectionality of Racism and Sexism. American culture absorbed the myth that all Black men were dangerous and sought to sexually assault white women. Meanwhile, Black women were taught to fear white men as potential assailants, a caution rooted in historical experience. As interracial relationships became more acceptable, hooks details how marriages between Black men and white women were viewed differently from those between white men and Black women. She asserts that because both Black men and white women were considered inferior within white patriarchal culture, those unions were more accepted, though Black men still faced racist violence from white men who viewed white women as their property and interracial marriages as sinful. A marriage between a white man and a Black woman, however, challenged accepted notions about status and power. Historically, when a woman married a man, she adopted his social status. Therefore, a Black woman who married a white man was considered to be of equal status—an idea that directly threatened white rule. hooks discusses how these ideas extend into the present day, asserting that interracial marriages between Black women and white men are less common than ones between white women and Black men. The Devaluation of Black Womanhood is a tool to keep white men in a position of authority within a patriarchal culture.